Neither is a reasonable alternative, in my view. That's why I believe we should stop considering impossible alternatives such as resettlement and deal with the way the world is, not how we would like it to be. The Road Map is our best hope of moving forward, in my opinion.
How, exactly, is the "Road Map" a recycle of the stupendous Oslo failure, a "step forward"? How will Israel achieve security through the "Road Map"? My opinion is that the terror will continue as it always has.
Look at "the way the world is:"
Arabs murder Jews until both need a breather, and then the Jews come in good faith to the bargaining table, only to be betrayed and murdered again by their "peace partners."
The Road Map is definitely right in line with that paradigm.