You are overly defensive, to the point of being blind. The reports of Elizabeth meeting with Mitchell are is the only scenario that makes any sense. It does not reflect on anything except the extreme naivete of a 14 year old girl and her family. You have to include the family because they had to have know about the visits. They also had to have observed Elizabeth talking to Mitchell the day that the mother brought him home.
The reports of Elizabeth meeting with Mitchell are is the only scenario that makes any sense.Only if you are predisposed, as you certainly are, to believe that this wasn't a case of a young girl who was victimized by monsters, but instead some sort of sordid "Lolita" episode.
Sorry, but most FReepers reject this entirely, and believe what Occam's Razor would suggest: That what happened is what happened, no more.