If your argument is valid regarding exclusionof Jews, it's also valid regarding atheists. Do you disagree?
(you may want to quote the post you are replying to, otherwise it's necessary to go back and find it to understand your reply)
It is, in a way. But the fact this country was founded believing in God, our coins have it, etc. it is not exclusionary, as this belief in God was set right when we were founded. Atheists know this, and they cannot do anything about it. They cannot object, as if they object, they therefore object to the way we were founded.