Talk about a complete non-starter. Widespread advocacy of this would turn America against conservatives for a generation. And dare I ask where we would send them, given that roughly half are converts or children of converts?
The only liberal value I find to be common in FR is to the idea that we need complete safety. In fact, there is a trade-off bewtween decency and legality on the one hand and safety on the other, and thank God the first hand is the one President Bush plays.