[dirtboy]

Although I find it extremely difficult to be sympathetic to an American caught in Taliban gang colors, I think it would be beneficial for the Administration to grant some limited access to Hamadi by lawyers so this issue can be put to rest.

[swarthyguy]

All well and good but Hamdi was picked up in Afghanistan on the battlefield,bearing arms against the US.

Hentoff is a solid guy, IMO, but making Hamdi a cause celebre is not going to make waves in the USA.

[Joe Brower]

Memo to Nat: When you start paying attention to the Second Amendment for a change, I'll start paying more attention to what you have to say.

[JohnGalt]

I hope the liberals are rethinking their silence when an arm of a the Internal Revenue Service burned 82 men, women, and children to death a decade ago.

I would like to agree with Mssr.Hentoff, but the left has no credibility on this issue and thus I have little choice but to trust Ashcroft has his reason for keeping this guy locked up.