To: HairOfTheDog; KneelBeforeZod
.........Haradrim, men from the lands South of Mordor............Easterlings........... If you check some of the more obscure Threads posted here at FR, there are a few where the authors criticize Tolkien's "racism". It is the characterization of these southerners (Africa?) and easterners (Muslims?) that has led to line of thought.
To: DoctorMichael
I know all about the line of thought! I have seen them.
I read the books without having a mental image of those peoples, even after reading it many times in my life, I didn't really need to picture them.
The moviemakers had to make an image though. The southerners... Haradrim, actually looked more Middle-Eastern to me... or northern Africa perhaps (due to the Oliphants). Their costumes, to my anthropologically untrained eye, looked nomadic Arabian or Bedouin-like. Notable though, the structures that the oliphants carried looked asian.
And the Easterlings in the film seemed very Oriental in design, to my eye.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson