Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: friendly; Winniesboy
I stand corrected if this is true that the UK's hospitals are all ultra-modern.

Hmmm. This is a a bit disengenuous. I don't think ukbird said all the hospitals here are now ultra-modern. He (she) said:

The UK is in the middle of the biggest hospital building programme in its history, with over 70 major hospital projects in progress or planned.

To me, this doesn't mean they tear down all the old hospitals, it says to me they are building or planning to build 70 new ones. This is a fairly ambitious project it seems to me, but even as small as the UK might seem to many Americans, 70 hospitals could fall into the UK and get lost and nobody in London would ever know what happened to them.

Here where I live in Scotland, we have a fairly new hospital. It was opened in 1988. I think you'd find a varying lot if you roamed across the UK- old hospitals and new.

One thing that happens with eyewitness reports... Let's say someone goes to the hospital and finds the floor dirty. Does this mean all the hospitals in the country are this way? No, of course not. I think papers like the Evening Standard and most of the citizens of London are very often guilty of forgetting that there is a whole big country out there beyond their city's borders and it isn't altogether comparable with London itself. Had the article's author toured Scotland's minor cities and towns he would have found hospitals that flew right in the face of the assertion he was making.

Take it for what it's worth. Here's a hospital in Pt Talbot, for example, that's being constructed right now. There is a programme here called PFI or Private Finance Iniative where the gov't is trying to move toward private sector funding of new hospitals. Here is an example of this (exerpts): Looking up the Hospital Front:

UNDER a UK Government initiative, new hospitals are being built and then operated for decades in partnership with private sector companies. AMEC is a leading player in the consortiums which are building and operating these new hospitals - recently completing Britain’s first and also winning the deal to build and run the latest and largest PFI hospital project in London . . .

...Built in the grounds of one of the old hospitals it replaces - which remained fully operational throughout construction - the £87 million, 444-bed hospital was financed, designed and constructed for Carlisle Hospitals NHS Trust in just 122 weeks by Health Management Carlisle (HMC), a consortium of AMEC and Building and Property Group...

...Meanwhile, a consortium that includes AMEC has won a £225 million deal to build and operate a magnificent new hospital in the heart of London. University College London Hospitals NHS Trust and private sector consortium Health Management UCLH plc, have finalised agreements for the design, financing, construction and operation of the huge project...

...When open, the state-of-the-art 669-bed facility will bring together all the NHS acute care facilities that are currently provided by The University College Hospital, The Middlesex Hospital, The Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Hospital and the Hospital for Tropical Diseases...

But the picture isn't quite as rosy as that. When you factor in trade unions you start to have complications.

Strike threat over private sector plan- source- BBC September 2001 (exerpts):

Union leaders are threatening strike action if the government's plans for public-private partnerships lead to worse conditions for workers...

The GMB released figures suggesting 24,000 hospital construction jobs could go as a result of lost investment due to PFI.

The union worked out that the £3bn it believes private companies will make out of PFI could have paid for 30 new hospitals, creating 75,000 posts for hospital staff besides the 24,000 jobs for construction workers.

It has emerged that three private finance hospital pilot schemes agreed in June have been put on hold.

So you see, new hospitals are being built but at the end of the day, a hospital is just a building. The UK is still facing shortages of doctors and key equipment. Concerns from Labor Unions, the huge cumbersome bureaucracy of the NHS, abuse of the "free" health system by citizens, doctor shortages, equipment shortages are all problems that make social medicine a substandard system. It's a much bigger, much more complicated problem...

33 posted on 12/13/2002 10:29:29 PM PST by Prodigal Son
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies ]


To: Prodigal Son
Correction to above post:

I don't think ukbird said all the hospitals here are now ultra-modern.

Should read: I don't think Winniesboy said...

I got confused for a second there. Sorry...
34 posted on 12/13/2002 10:31:42 PM PST by Prodigal Son
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 33 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson