I'll give you this one. The Bush we all know and love. 43 has also screwed his pooch among California conservatives in 2004 over another of his brilliant domestic policies .. open boarders.
I'll bet 43 is glad there's an electoral college.
I find statements like this hilarious. Typical of the "I'm a wonk, you're a wonk, wouldn't you like to be a wonk, too?" attitude that prevails among the politically informed.
NEWS FLASH: The typical voter doesn't give a hoot 'n' holler who the SecTreas is. Not one iota's worth of a d*mn.
If you ask the typical voter, in Louisiana, who Paul O'Neill is, 90% would give you a blank stare. If you asked "what do you think of Pres. Bush's replacement of Paul O'Neill at Treasury? Do you support the President or oppose his move?" 90% (or more) would say "support," because everyone knows who Pres. Bush is, everyone--even in Louisiana--supports Pres. Bush, and the assumption would be if our trusted President replaced some guy it must have been the right decision.
This had ZILCH, ZIP, ZERO, NADA, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with the election results in Louisiana.
FWIW, I think your other points were good. Just this one is way, way off base.