[berned]

Ok. So WHAT, specifically is Polycarp accusing me of "lying" about? (Since Polycarp is doing one of his patented "drive-by accusations" -- where he runs away, refusing even to clarify his accusations.)

Polycarp called ME to this thread. I have answered forthrightly. For my trouble, that great Christian Polycarp has called me "a chump" and "a liar". Okay... what, pray tell did I "lie" about?

[SoothingDave]

Ok. So WHAT, specifically is Polycarp accusing me of "lying" about?

It would seem that today's accusation comes from you attibuting words to him, that were actually words that he posted from another apologist.

But, in general, it is that you think this ossuary, even if authentic, proves anything about Mary's Perpetual Virginity. That even though the idea of Joseph having a previous wife is plausible, you persist in the idea that it is not.

SD