Replies

Very well then, here is one of your lies concerning what I had said. It is a clear misrepresentation of both my words and my intent. Then, what we have here is FormerLib's admission that the Celtic Orthodox taught Calvinist-Presbyterian sacramental theology. (And Calvinist salvation theology, and Calvinist predestination theology, et cetera, et cetera) Now that you have your proof, kindly leave me alone. Do not ping me again to this or any other thread. Do you understand this?

No, that doesn't cut it.

You accuse me of Lying. That's a Lie. Your Lies will not go unresponded.

"The Sacraments of the Altar are not the real Body and Blood of Christ, but only the commemoration of his Body and Blood." ~~ Johannis Scotus Erigena

You acknowledge that Erigena's statement was, by Eastern Orthodox standard, "heresy".
You acknowledge that Calvinist Presbyterians teach, on Eucharistic matters, the same "heresy".

If A = C "heresy", and B = C "heresy", then A DOES EQUAL B. Therefore:

Given that you do acknowledge the teaching of the same "heresy" by both Celtic Orthodox and Calvinist Presbyterians, you HAVE admitted that the Celtic Orthodox taught Calvinist-Presbyterian sacramental theology.

Therefore I did not Lie; and therefore, you did Bear False Witness that I had done so.

Erigena taught that "The Sacraments of the Altar are not the real Body and Blood of Christ, but only the commemoration of his Body and Blood."
Calvinists teach that "The Sacraments of the Altar are not the real Body and Blood of Christ, but only the commemoration of his Body and Blood."
You accused me of Lying when I said both taught the same teaching.
As can clearly be seen, they ARE exactly the same teaching.
Therefore, YOU lied about ME.

And those are the facts of the case.