Replies

You don't say what your primary use will be, for this gun. These are not good choices, for a carry gun. They are both on the large side, which may also make them bad choices. [not bad guns, they are two of the best] As a dealer, I would suggest that you go to a local dealer and try the fit, of the different guns, in your hand. [if the dealer is not willing to help you find a gun that fits you, or wants to TELL you what you should buy, find another dealer] If you know someone that owns guns, ask if you can try different calibers and types. [good idea to offer to supply the ammo] Most any good quality gun would last lifetime. [tests have shown that most auto-loaders don't reach maximum accuracy potential till they have about 4000 rounds fired] You need to make up your mind on the features you want. Like single or double action, if it has a positive safety, and all metal or polymer frame. [weight is a major concern for a carry gun] With modern bullets, most any caliber can do a reasonable job for self defense. Larger calibers do come with more recoil, but anyone can learn to shoot any caliber, with practice. The main thing is to get what fits your needs and fits your hand. When you determine what YOU want, don't let anyone change your mind!! To be effective for self defense, you have to be ready and able to use your firearm without thinking about it. If the gun is too big or you are uncomfortable about using it, it's not the correct one for you. Good Luck with your quest for a new gun.

You don't say what your primary use will be, for this gun.

To shoot bad guys with if they approach me in a menacing manner. Teasing you now...

I just wanted to move up to a semi-automtic that was not too terribly heavy with a full clip. The .357 snub I own is fine for home. I'm not so worried about recoil, this can be overcome with practice and adjustment. Weight is a concern. I wanted opinions of others who own these type guns. Thanks for your valuable input.