[RadioAstronomer]

Well you must have missed the orbits/circle/ellipse arguments then.

[VadeRetro]

Well you must have missed the orbits/circle/ellipse arguments then.

He misses everything, and sees what isn't there. Morton's Demon.

[Ahban]

RA would it make you feel any better if I counted that one and said 15-6? Well, at any rate YOU are the astronomer so it would be surprising if an amateur could compete with you in your specialty.

I don't even want to get hung up on what we each think the record is, I just want to get back to debating the real issues, not who is a coward or whatever.

The win-loss estimates are mostly matters of opinion anyway. I suppose if you define victory as "showing what looks like a graduated series, even if we know that some forms in the series do not belong in there" then I guess Vade is up 20-0. Maybe 19-1 because of that origin of life thread. OR did you have the good sense to not entangle yourself in that one much? At any rate, the main point is actaully debating the facts, not whose mamma wears combat boots.