I first mentioned it
here, but I don't think I was even the first on that thread to suppose it... when dealing with gypsies, always assume you are being lied to about everything. If they say the sun rises in the east, get up the next morning expecting in the west.
I admit, I was ready to break out the tinfoil when I read posters speculating about the child being switched. If this is really NOT the same child....I will NEVER doubt FReepers again.