To: APBaer
Before trial all the prosecutor has to disclose to the defendant is so called Brady material, that is material that is exculpatory.
Do you mean a defendant doesnt have any real discovery rights, to ask for all documents related to this or that, for example?
patent +AMDG
11 posted on
09/25/2002 8:48:02 PM PDT by
patent
To: patent
"Do you mean a defendant doesnt have any real discovery rights, to ask for all documents related to this or that, for example?"
Yes, I know that it seems backwards, what with a person's personal liberty at stake in a criminal proceeding, that there is no right to liberal discovery of the opponent (the porsecutor)like there is in a civil proceeding.
In some Federal Judicial Districts, as "a matter of grace" the prosecutors may have an "open file policy" that is not the general policy, and it is certainly not a right.
A federal criminal trial is much more of an old fashioned "trial by ambush," which was eliminated in civil trials by generous pretrial discovery.
12 posted on
09/25/2002 9:42:05 PM PDT by
APBaer
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson