No doubt, it would be the best "convertible" of all time, if only it had a top of some kind.
Mazda Miata. Hands down.
I'll conceed that the Miata is certainly the most successful drop-top to come along in a long, long time. I think it falls a big short in the "All-time Best" ratings, though - and that may be more due to nostalgia than anything else.
That said, here's my favorite:
1968-1/2 Shelby GT-500 KR, viewed from the angle most familiar to everything else on the road.