Iraq: Pentagon Plan the Last One Standing

Summary

Retired Gen. Wayne Downing, a key figure in the debate over how to fight Iraq, has resigned, leaving a clearer path for a Pentagon proposal nicknamed "Desert Storm Lite." But even without the opposition posed by Downing, the Pentagon's plan for ousting Iraqi President Saddam Hussein may prove unworkable.

Analysis

Gen. Wayne Downing, who was brought out of retirement after Sept. 11 to serve as a deputy national security adviser, resigned suddenly from the anti-terrorism position on June 27. Downing, who was a four-star Army general and the former chief of Special Operations Command, departs only nine months after taking the White House job.

Although his official duties focused on the al Qaeda threat, Downing was one of the loudest voices in the debate over the necessity and methods for destroying the regime of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein. An unabashed hawk, Downing countered the Pentagon's Iraq proposal, nicknamed "Desert Storm Lite," with an unconventional plan that relied on air power, special operations forces and Iraqi defectors to oust Hussein. The general's departure removes one of the last nodes of opposition to the Pentagon's approach, but this does not necessarily mean an acceleration in war-planning or preparations, or even a final decision on a military strike.

Earlier this year, when war cries against Iraq were at a much higher pitch, the Pentagon hatched a plan for a military campaign against Baghdad that was very similar to that followed during the Gulf War. A 200,000-strong force of armor, infantry and aircraft would be assembled over two to three months, presumably in Kuwait and Turkey, and unleashed against Iraq's 500,000 soldiers.

Both U.S. President George W. Bush and Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld publicly blasted Pentagon planners for their lack of creativity. However, between the lines the Pentagon was advising caution -- suggesting that the White House should ease off its strident anti-Hussein posture.

Downing played a key role in this debate. He had advised the opposition Iraqi National Congress since 1998 and helped the group refine a plan for overthrowing Hussein. That plan, drawn up before Sept. 11, looked quite similar to the later U.S. campaign against the Taliban: Special Operations troops would advise and train local fighters, who would seize a deserted air base in southern Iraq under U.S. air cover. Any Iraqi units massed to attack the airfield would be destroyed from the air while isolated units would be encouraged to defect.

Downing's plan had a few advocates, especially among civilian staff in the Pentagon and White House. And his anti-terrorism position gave him a soapbox from which to plug the issue.

The reasons behind Downing's departure are unclear. Media reports suggest everything from frustration with the slow pace of government to disenchantment with his inability to exercise sole control over anti-terrorism efforts.

Whatever the reason, his departure means "Desert Storm Lite" is essentially the sole remaining proposal for ousting Hussein -- but that doesn't mean an invasion of Iraq is imminent. From a logistical perspective, executing the Pentagon's strategy would require a substantial amount of planning and material preparation, which would be made even more difficult by the current dispersal of U.S. forces around the globe.

However, the strategy is complicated mainly by political factors. Washington almost certainly wants the Middle East, Afghanistan and Pakistan to calm down somewhat before it gets involved in an entirely new crisis. Also, Arab states would need to be in relative agreement with the U.S. plan.

The complexity of the Pentagon's plan actually may push back the start of a campaign or cause it to be shelved indefinitely.

The reasons behind Downing's departure are unclear. Media reports suggest everything from frustration with the slow pace of government to disenchantment with his inability to exercise sole control over anti-terrorism efforts

Perhaps it was something as benign as the realization that his work was done?

Or perhaps it is the old mis-direction. Maybe now the Iraqi's will be looking for a huge build-up of forces. When they don't see it they relax and boom, the bombing starts. We just don't know what is going on but I would suggest that anything is possible. It's called strategery

"Also, Arab states would need to be in relative agreement with the U.S. plan."

Says WHO?????

The reasons behind Downing's departure are unclear.

I would really like to know the true reasons for Downing's abrupt departure.

IIRCorrectly from a David Schippers' radio interview, Schippers mentioned trying to get information that he couldn't get directly to Ashcroft at least he'd try to get it to General (ret) Downing.

There's got to be more to this story about Downing's departure than meets the eye.

I don't understand why Downings plan isn't used to open the war with Iraq. Presuming it doesn't succeed initially, then it could be an excellent starting point for the more conventional war to follow. If it does work, then so much the better.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.