Replies

Not only does this guy not match the description given by Mary Katherine, the milkman said that he's not the guy he saw that morning after he saw the picture, according to earlier posters here today.

Maybe the guy's guilty as sin, but if he's this sloppy about getting away, it's hard to believe he's clever enough to break into an occupied house and get back out again with a young girl without being detected.

He was living in his car. It's not that unusual that he could be hanging out in the park regularly, (drinking beer?), and happened to be there during the vigil. He knew he had outstanding warrants so when the cops approached he ran.

I have no idea...it just smells like a red herring to me. The guy has no history of sexual crimes.

There is something else. Remember the convenience store surveillance camera taping someone steeling beer? Everyone thought it was him, then that fizzled out too. I think that was before the vigil.

The beer-swigging Edmunds sounds a lot like the TV character (many years ago) Jim Rockford,P.I....hanging around, looking disheveled, seen here and there. Maybe an undercover FBI guy? When they didn't pick him up at the park at the vigil...little alarms went off. Come on, now--the cops see a guy who may be holding captive a young girl kidnapped from her home--and they don't throw him on the ground and cuff him? This is all so strange.