[Orion]

I believe that you must enlist in the army of a foreign state (Isreal exempted for political reasons) to lose your citizenship. Walker joined a criminal organization, not the Afghan army, or our govt' would be treating all the "detainees" at Gitmo as POWs.

Our gov't would never want it both ways...Nope, not here in the good ol USA. We ALWAYS abide by the law.

[McGavin999]

They are not citizens, he is, or at least is was. I think it's going to be up for grabs on whether or not he can lose his citizenship. He fired on members of the US Military. He took part in an uprising at Mazar-e-shariff, he could have surrendered to the US agent when he was being questioned. He fired on the US Military AFTER he had the opportunity to surrender. He can't say he was not aware he was fighting against America since US Military represents America.

You can apologize for him all you want. It doesn't make him any less dispicable. I still want him to lose his citizenship and be deported. Whether that happens or not remains to be seen.

[McGavin999]

Oh, BTW, neither of the two cases I showed you had their citizenship revoked for fighting in a foreign army.