The "observation" that the cell is irreducible is far from being well-established. When a leftie like Commoner takes a position like that I'm naturally suspicious that he has some hidden agenda. I really don't trust him. That's all I'm saying. When the weight of professional opinion goes the same way, based on verifiable evidence we can all appreciate, I'll be ready to accept such a conclusion. But not on Commoner's say-so. I put him in the same boat with Hillary, notwithstanding his claim to being a biologist. Here's an example of Commoner's "science" opinions:
Barry Commoner: A leading environmentalist reviews his long, contentious past.