Regarding Ron Santo, if he's in, why not Craig Nettles as well? Nettles had better lifetime stats (while playing longer), and was a much better fielder.
Santo won 5 Gold Gloves, Nettles won two. Nettles was never the best third baseman in his leage, Brooks passed that torch to Brett. Santo was a 9 time All Star, Nettles was picked six times.
BaseballReference.com has stastical methods of breaking down Hall of Famers and likely HoFers. Check it out...