[WhiskeyPapa]

I stopped responding to WP's crap last week when he tried to imply that I was lying about whether I had ever read Martin v. Hunter's Lessee while in college.

I didn't -imply- anything. You're lying. I stated plainly that you've lied.

You lie in this post too. Chief Justice Jay clearly states in his ruling on Chisholm that the states -transferred- certain elements of sovereignty to the federal government. The states retain -other- elements of sovereignty. It is wrong to say that I -ever- said that the states were not sovereign, or that the ruling says that.

So you are caught again in unclever deception, and flat lies.

Walt

[billbears]

It is wrong to say that I -ever- said that the states were not sovereign

Well which is it? Either the states are sovereign on everything except what is covered in the Constitution or they aren't.