Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Hard times for U.S. Muslims
The Indianapolis Star ^ | December 16, 2001 | SHAHID ATHAR

Posted on 12/16/2001 4:36:38 AM PST by sarcasm

click here to read article


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 61-8081-100101-120121-124 next last
To: JCG
With all due respect, there is NO EVIDENCE AT ALL that the inflated number of 6 to 8,000,000 Muslims in the USA has any validity. I looked at the link you yourself provided, and the Staet Department's estimate, which was put together by some anonymnous worker who did a quick naive search on what numbers are floating around, had THIS as the entire basis for population estimates:

[Footnote] 3 Estimates vary widely for all the figures quoted throughout this fact sheet. In terms of overall population, M.M. Ali reports that there are 6 to 8 million Muslims in America in The Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, May-June 1996, p. 13.

So a Muslim guy invents a number and the State Department repeats it. That proves absolutely nothing. The correct number, produced after an actual survey by an unbiased survey company, is more like 1,800,000.

101 posted on 12/16/2001 1:49:56 PM PST by wildandcrazyrussian
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies]

To: wildandcrazyrussian
So a Muslim guy invents a number and the State Department repeats it. That proves absolutely nothing. The correct number, produced after an actual survey by an unbiased survey company, is more like 1,800,000.

The only time I've seen your number it was from the ADL.  My number is from the US State Department.  You say some "Muslim guy" invented it.  You have no -- repeat, no -- proof of that.  If you're going to challenge my number do it with something factual, like that "unbiased survey company."  Who is it?

America's Fifth Column ... watch PBS documentary JIHAD! In America
Download 8 Mb zip file here (60 minute video)

102 posted on 12/16/2001 5:50:09 PM PST by JCG
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 101 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
Muslims:

If there is any question in your minds about whether or not to stay in America and live as our patriot brothers, then I implore you: LEAVE.

103 posted on 12/16/2001 5:54:28 PM PST by cicero's_son
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: not-an-ostrich
500 does sound high. If people want to say 500, let us see 500 names.
104 posted on 12/16/2001 6:07:22 PM PST by Freedom of Speech Wins
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: RippleFire
Hope his patients have the opportunity to read this column. I hope they have the brains to take their business elsewhere.



105 posted on 12/16/2001 6:13:53 PM PST by who knows what evil?
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

To: Freedom of Speech Wins
500 does sound high. If people want to say 500, let us see 500 names.

Probably gets his numbers from the 'Major Owens Institute of Inflated Math'.



106 posted on 12/16/2001 6:15:50 PM PST by who knows what evil?
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 104 | View Replies]

To: all
I realize I am coming in to the discussion late (sorry if much of this has already been said), but have some two-cents from an opinion I posted on 9/28/01... link to that thread and text below:

How do we fight terrorism without being impolite to muslims
subtitle: Why are we so screwed up that BLIND political correctness is our priority right now?

I am sorry that Muslims are being shouted at from pickup trucks... because shouting from pickup trucks is unseemly and ineffective. But constantly tripping over ourselves apologizing to Muslims who are just "normal Americans" is going to ensure that we lose.

These terrorists make an art of coming to this country, making friends and seeming very normal for many years, taking full advantage of our political correctness, our free right of travel, our education in universities, our flight training, and while they are here they study our weaknesses, not the least of which is our desire to be completely trusting and accepting of them.

The hijackers who did this did not wear "Terrorist in Training" T-shirts. They looked very much like those who claim to be unfairly treated now, and also look like those that I have seen walking through Seattle trying not to make eye contact with anyone... I am very vigilant at watching them now.... I wonder what they think, whether they know one of them, whether they are one of them. I know they feel me watching them, and I hope they are getting mad... Not mad at me, but mad at those among them that are causing my fear.

I guarantee that my mistrust of Middle-Eastern Muslims will grow and not diminish, until there are long lines of Muslims waiting at police precincts to report suspicious behavior among them, and until the interviews shown on television are NOT people of European decent full of guilt at their own mistrusting thoughts telling us how to behave and what to think.

My mistrust will diminish when those Middle-Eastern Muslims here in America are the most vocal about rooting out this problem. The problem is that those that are speaking up so far are those that feel victimized unfairly, or offer vague references that Islam is a religion of peace, and not terror. Clearly there are lots of Muslims who have read something else. Where are those that have overheard discussions, but did not participate? Where are those that have been approached to participate or give money, but chose not to? Where are those that were trusted enough to confide in, but did not decide to join? Or those that joined ethnic or Muslim groups they believed to improve people's lives, only to find out that the real mission was something very different? Where are those that are vocal about exposing those among them that are the problem? Until they speak up, I will continue to mistrust all of them without feeling an ounce of guilt, because I refuse to feel guiltier than they do about these attacks on our country.

Remember grade school, when the teacher needed to know which student in the class had stolen Suzie's crayons? And all students were forced to stay after class until the guilty party confessed, or his friends ratted him out? Everyone in the class faced equal suspicion until the common desire to go to recess was greater than the embarrassment of confession. The peer pressure to end the detention of everyone turned toward finding the evil-doer within. Well, I for one will continue to blame the whole class rather than be made a fool of when they strike again while we do our best to be polite.

I have no doubt that America can take out all the terrorists and supporters that they find. But killing them from the outside will never really solve the problem. Weaken it maybe, make money harder to raise maybe, keep them running maybe, but we do not have a lock on craftiness and talent. Outsiders can never get them all, and will probably create more enemies as we try. Only "they" can solve this problem, and it is imperative that we compel them to do so, or assume they are guilty if they do not.

We should be very afraid that Muslims here and abroad that have been our friends when we could help them are only quietly and half-heartedly helping us now, trying not to be overly offensive to their own. We should be very afraid that Muslims in this country are silently trying to keep their heads down. I am very afraid that many Muslims in this country know more than they have admitted, and yet want the benefit of the doubt from me.

Let us not seem hysterical by shouting at them from pickup trucks, but let us never let political correctness allow us to be blindsided again...

107 posted on 12/16/2001 6:44:05 PM PST by HairOfTheDog
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 106 | View Replies]

To: Matchett-PI
"Here's the CONTEST -- Who's got the best tag line for Islam. Here's my entry to start: ISLAM -- THE RELIGION THAT LOVES TO HATE." "Islam -- Terrorists didn't hijack it, they just took it seriously." GREAT ONE -- MATCHETT-PI -- COULDN'T AGREE MORE!! THANKS. JRLC
108 posted on 12/16/2001 8:11:24 PM PST by jrlc
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 96 | View Replies]

To: JCG;wildandcrazyrussian
Here are two links for you guys. Estimates of muslim population as a result of immigration have a higher degree of accuracy than guesses about how many people may have converted to islam after they were already here.

story in Florida paper about studies in Chicago and New York disputing higher estimate

estimate of five million from American Muslim Council
109 posted on 12/16/2001 8:13:07 PM PST by ganesha
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 102 | View Replies]

To: ganesha
Here are two links for you guys. Estimates of muslim population as a result of immigration have a higher degree of accuracy than guesses about how many people may have converted to islam after they were already here.

Thanks for the links but is there any reason why the US State Department numbers can't be trusted?  (Other than the fact that the government can't be trusted.  Hehe.)

America's Fifth Column ... watch PBS documentary JIHAD! In America
Download 8 Mb zip file here (60 minute video)

110 posted on 12/17/2001 2:59:24 AM PST by JCG
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 109 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
All the progress made in the growth of Islam in our country for the last 50 years seems to be reversed,

Well, seems Osama's plan wasn't too successful, if selling his brand of religious tyranny was the end goal.

... and some immigrant Muslims have started to question whether they should go back to their countries of origin.

Let me make that decision easier for you ...

111 posted on 12/17/2001 3:19:07 AM PST by IronJack
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
They sure have a hard time indeed .... telling us about what is going on, that is.

Reuters Photo

Uniformed children stand in units named after guerrillas killed fighting Israel as part of Hizbollah's Jerusalem day rally December 14, 2001 in Beirut. The head of Lebanon's Hizbollah guerrilla group urged Palestinians to launch more suicide bomb attacks on Israelis and defy U.S.-led demands to crack down on 'terrorist' militant groups. (Sharif Karim/Reuters)

112 posted on 12/17/2001 3:20:52 AM PST by lavaroise
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
Should they side with the terrorists overseas or with the superpower that is bombing the innocent civilians in hospitals and houses in Afghanistan in order to free the world of these terrorists?

That is why you don't belong here! No one should even think for a moment about supporting terrorists of any kind. Your hearts are in the homeland---well go to the homeland. Make your own countries into places that you would want to live. The reason you come here is because we have built a beautiful country because we are GOOD PEOPLE. You are BAD PEOPLE. You are not nice. You will never create anything wonderful or magnificent. You will never write a beautiful song--or even a good bad song. No, "I'll Be Seeing You" or "I Am I Said" or "I Want to Hold Your Hand" or even "Material Girl" will ever be written or sung by your people.

You will never write a great movie. A great book. Or paint a great painting. You will never have a choir of bright and shining faces singing so beautifully that the joy in their hearts makes your own heart melt.

God did not choose you. You chose to follow a 'religion' that is a perversion. If you were born to cannibals, it wouldn't make being a cannibal the right thing to be! You would have to change! Well, wake up. You people have to change. Look at what Mohammed was and what he did. You should be ashamed to follow him. You should throw out the veils and let your women lift their faces to the sunshine and learn to smile. Let them understand that they shouldn't have children in order for these children to strap dynamite around their waists in order to die to go to paradise to rape virgins. It is not logical. It is not nice. It is STUPID!

Go back to where your heart is--far away from America. We are good people. Kind. Generous. You just don't belong and you never will.

Want to know why you should leave? We will never trust you again. Never.

113 posted on 12/17/2001 3:26:25 AM PST by IceGirl2
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
"...., nor can we be interned. "

Don't bet on it raghead!

I don't see any reason for this man's confusion. Either you're a terrorist or not. Some of the things he says in this essay are laudible, however, words w/o actions are meaningless. If the Moslems want to live in this country then a minimal level of citizenship is required. Ifyou have a problem w/ that you're gonna have a problem w/ me.

114 posted on 12/17/2001 3:35:46 AM PST by Pietro
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
He can be reached by e-mail at sathar3624@aol.com

ROFL

What the heck was this guy thinking, when he let them publish his email address? I can just imagine the list of subject lines, alone, right now. :-P

115 posted on 12/17/2001 4:04:31 AM PST by B Knotts
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: who knows what evil?; Freedom of Speech Wins
500 does sound high. If people want to say 500, let us see 500 names.

>Probably gets his numbers from the 'Major Owens Institute of Inflated Math'.

Maybe Screwy Louie Farrakan's Million Man Math? (1.5M *.wav)

116 posted on 12/17/2001 4:16:06 AM PST by FreedomPoster
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 106 | View Replies]

To: JCG;ganesha
But my main point is that they AREN'T "State Department numbers". They are simply numbers MENTIONED BY some unknown person in the State Department. It would be as though I sent ganesha an e-mail stating that JCG owed me a million dollars, and ganesha repeated it thinking it's accurate when it's not. Your reliance on the authority of the USDOS when they DO NOT CLAIM to have produced the numbers in the first place makes me wonder. Their own footnote states where the staff person got it, and then incorporated it in good faith, unaware that sometimes people exaggerate things for their own benefit.

Isn't it the least bit plausible that Islamic groups would exaggerate their own numbers enough to knock Judaism out of second place in the list of major religions in the USA, with all the ramifications that such a belief would help bring about in foreign policy?

I read the figure of 1,800,000 from several surveys done by disinterested survey groups such as the Barna survey company, which concentrates on religious identifications and attitudes.

Just by comparison, one frequently reads estimates from Eastern Orthodox Christian groups that there are 6,000,000 Orthodox faithful in the USA, and I (as a life-long Orthodox) don't believe a word of it. I estimate no more than 1-1,500,000 myself, no matter what somebody official says. The math is that for such an estimate to be true, then every 50th person in the USA would be Orthodox, and I would see at lot more than 2,200 Orthodox churches many of which have small congregations. I can more readily believe that there are a million of us Orthodox and that half hardly ever attend church, than I would believe that there are 6 million and 90% hardly ever go to church.

Well, on the same basis, there would have to be SOME evidence that there are such large numbers of Muslims since I have never yet met one outside of college (30 years ago). Nor have I ever ever even seen a mosque in the USA. Let's just stick to verifiable truth.

117 posted on 12/17/2001 5:19:28 AM PST by wildandcrazyrussian
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 110 | View Replies]

To: FreedomPoster
That's a CLASSIC howler! Thanks for the reminder! LOL!



118 posted on 12/17/2001 5:36:40 AM PST by who knows what evil?
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 116 | View Replies]

To: sarcasm
Should they side with the terrorists overseas or with the superpower that is bombing the innocent civilians in hospitals and houses in Afghanistan in order to free the world of these terrorists?

I got to here and saw the clear evidence that this guy is just another mohammedan anti-american. Why can't they just come out and admit that islam is NOT a religion of peace.

No need to read the rest.

God (Yahweh, Jehovah, Jesus) Save America (Please)

119 posted on 12/17/2001 7:38:32 AM PST by John O
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: not-an-ostrich
From the source:

Athar, M.D., is past president of the Islamic Society of Greater Indianapolis and the author of numerous articles on Islam.

He's not a journalist, but he is still a professional liar :-)

120 posted on 12/17/2001 11:05:58 AM PST by xm177e2
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 61-8081-100101-120121-124 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson