I get those two mixed up also. But my personal favorite is either "Swing Time" or "Carefree".
Least favorite: Roberta (awful!). And yours?
Boy, I'll have to pull some of those videos out now that I'm reminiscing...that would be a nice escape.
I really like both " TOP HAT " & " THE GAY DIVORCEE " ( even if they meld into one movie, in my brain. LOL ) , and have a soft spot for " THE STORY OF VERNON & IRENE CASTLE". " SWING TIME" and " SHALL WE DANCE " are also my favorites. Gee , I don't think that I have one favorite; I just REALLY like Fred & Ginger movies. : - )
Oh, I just remembered ; I HATE " THE BARCLEYS OF BROADWAT"!