[eastsider]

Why do you suppose the name of Mary disappears from Scripture after the accension of Jesus? Is it because her role has been accomplished?

An argument from silence? Surely you can do better than that!

[JohnnyM]

its better than pulling it out of thin air.

JM

[OLD REGGIE]

An argument from silence? Surely you can do better than that!

As a matter of fact, I could quote many early Church Fathers but I will leave it to you to show the opposite.

Surely the arguments of Perpetual Virginity and Bodily Assumption are arguments from noise. You must do better than that.