How does my "thought experiment" differ from that fine definition?
SD
Your experiment seemed a little vague to me.
I agree with JohnnyM when he said that if the church Mr. C went to was the Mormon Church, he would then be right to seperate from it. However, if his thoughts led him to stray from a sound Independant Baptist Church, then he would of course be wrong. ;^)
Seriously, your experiment seemed to focused on Mr. C's feelings. Our feelings are not the Holy Spirit. Our feelings can easily be manipulated.
-ksen