[SoothingDave]

What exactly is it about the list of the Popes that makes you think that this historical fact is supposed to be a matter covered infallibly?

SD

[OLD REGGIE]

What exactly is it about the list of the Popes that makes you think that this historical fact is supposed to be a matter covered infallibly?

Where in the world do you get, or invent, the idea I think the "List of Popes" is claimed to be infallible? What historical fact? The fact there is no historical fact? The only "fact" is, there is no verifiable List of Popes. If I were a skeptic I'd say the list is fiction. I might go even further and suggest to Becky that Peter didn't know he was "Pope" because he wasn't during his lifetime. He was elected posthumously and he selected his "successor" posthumously.