There's certainly some logic to what you say, but if we're going to enlist the cooperation of Arab and Muslim governments, we can't do it at the same time we're expelling people because of Arab or Muslim origin.
For what you say to work, we'd have to come to a decision that we're going it alone in the fight against terrorism. We may be able to, I think Europe is more compromised.
I do favor the immediate development of synthetic, non-polluting fuels/energy sources to reduce or eliminate dependence on oil supply disruptions.
At that point in the war, trade and travel between the West and the middle east will be finished, inluding oil.