Posted on 09/12/2001 1:09:42 AM PDT by kattracks
NEW YORK (AP) - The World Trade Center's twin towers were two of America's most visible symbols of engineering prowess, so when they crashed to the ground in an avalanche of ash, many asked how it could have happened.
Experts in skyscraper design and construction say it was probably simple: The 110-story towers were conceived to withstand powerful impacts, but their steel skeletons couldn't protect them from thousands of gallons of flaming jet fuel.
"Steel melts, and 24,000 gallons of aviation fluid melted the steel. Nothing is designed or will be designed to withstand that fire," said Hyman Brown, a University of Colorado civil engineering professor and the Trade Center's construction manager.
"If they did it lower in the building, the fire department could have gotten to it sooner. In its simplicity, it was brilliant," he said.
Masoud Sanayei, a civil engineering professor at Tufts University, said the fire's heat may have disconnected one of the towers' concrete floors from the tubular steel columns ringing the buildings. If one or two floors collapsed, it would have created a pancake effect of one massive floor caving into the next.
"In my opinion, the fire weakened the connection between the floor system and the columns on the higher floors and caused a couple of the floors to collapse," Sanayei said. "The floors are very heavy, made of reinforced concrete, so when one hits the next, they cause a domino effect ... and it can go all the way down to the first floor."
He said no one could be expected to survive such a catastrophe.
Brown, too, noted that although the twin towers had staircases in all four corners for evacuation, video clips led him to believe those escape routes were cut off for people on higher floors long before the buildings collapsed.
Architect Minoru Yamasaki, who died in 1986, worked with engineers John Skilling and Leslie E. Robertson to design the twin towers, once the world's tallest buildings.
In his 2000 book "Building Big," architect David MaCaulay described the towers' engineering as "a series of load bearing exterior columns spaced 3 feet apart and tied together at every floor by a deep horizontal beam, creating a strong lattice of square tubing around each tower."
The core surrounding the elevators inside was much the same, with a giant lattice work of steel covered by poured concrete connecting the interior columns to the exterior ones. The design was free enough for each of the towers to hold 4 million square feet of space unencumbered by columns or load bearing walls.
Sections of exterior wall were wrapped around the outside in 24- and 36-foot high sections, creating a sort of patchwork so that not all the floor joints would meet walls at the same height, according to MaCaulay.
Minoru Yamasaki Associates issued a statement saying the firm was in contact with authorities and had offered assistance.
"We believe that any speculation regarding the specifics of these tragic events would be irresponsible," the statement said. "For obvious reasons, MYA has no further comment at this time."
Then comes progressive collapse, and it's all over.
I feel vindicated about my previous posts on this subject to other articles.
Well before that cascading collapse began most of those poor souls were already doomed.May God have mercy on them!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.