Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Immigrants’ Historical Effects on Government Budgets: 1900–2023
CATO INSTITUTE ^ | 11/17/26 | David J. Bier, Julián Salazar

Posted on 11/18/2026 12:52:32 PM PST by spintreebob

Critics of immigration often claim that it was once fiscally positive for the US but that the welfare state ended the fiscal upside. This paper details how immigrants have reduced government deficits every year for the last 124 years by a cumulative $14.6 trillion—not counting savings on interest payments on a smaller debt. As a share of GDP, the immigrant surplus was more than twice as fiscally beneficial in 2023 as in 1913—before the modern welfare state and individual federal income tax. In inflation-adjusted terms, immigrants were 53 times more beneficial to public budgets in 2023 than in 1913.

Immigrants today are vastly more productive—and thus pay more in taxes per capita in inflation-adjusted terms—than those in 1913, creating a much larger net fiscal surplus.

Congress should build on this success by further limiting the scope of the welfare state and expanding legal immigration. ....

(Excerpt) Read more at cato.org ...


TOPICS: Business/Economy; Crime/Corruption; Culture/Society; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: immigrants; produictive; welfarestate

Click here: to donate by Credit Card

Or here: to donate by PayPal

Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794

Thank you very much and God bless you.

"Limit welfare state" is the key. Not all immigrants are the same. The key distinction is not visa or no visa. The key is asset or liability to society.

Keep out and deport naturalized, legal and illegal who 1) give aid and comfort to Hamas, terrorists, enemies of the US. 2) murder, rape... DUI, Drunk n Disorderly. 3) apply for welfare, benefits for self or anchor babies. 4) lie on visa, other documents

It is a PRIVILEGE, not a RIGHT, to live in the USA. Deny and revoke that privilege to the above 4 categories.

Given the recent flip of TX and others Congress will be making changes. Our position should be to seek a compromise our direction. But that compromise should have limits.

The key to the compromise is that some immigrants are an asset and some are a liability. We need to incentivize the assets and discourage the liabilities both in entering, and in behavior once here.

More Details: People come here as H1b or one of many visa categories. They flip between illegal and legal visa categories often. Many illegals are "between" visa categories. The visa categories should enforce our values. For example: Many Deloitte H1b are on welfare...not that they are defined as welfare recipients but as H1b they are afraid to speak out and be whistleblowers is the primary criteria for their H1b. That some are incompetent in IT and many don't understand US or state law and custom is a minor criteria in their H1b status. That has to change. Since "no visa" is such a large category, it is obvious that we need to change the category definitions and the way they are applied.

I suggest less categories with the 4 criteria at the top and easier movement between categories as key in all those categories.

Our response must bring together both Heritage types and CATO types on the right and convince enough Democrats to pass Congress. If we don't put together a reasonable plan, the other side will win with a very unreasonable plan.

1 posted on 11/18/2026 12:52:32 PM PST by spintreebob
[ Post Reply]

To: spintreebob

If you don’t distinguish legal and illegal immigrants, you’re just a propagandist.


2 posted on 11/18/2026 12:55:10 PM PST by csn vinnie
[ Post Reply]

To: csn vinnie

They are mostly indistinguishable, legal, illegal, it is all the same mix and the same people, the same erasure of our nation, and the same destruction of our future.


3 posted on 11/18/2026 1:02:01 PM PST by ansel12 (Cats wouldn't text you, but pray that dogs never learn how to text.)
[ Post Reply]

To: csn vinnie

And thus the push for amnesty has begun.

I will say, I don’t doubt that immigrants were indeed in that positive before the welfare state.

But I don’t believe for a second that the mass of people in this country today illegally are enormous net drain on this Society, and not just due wholly to the welfare state.

I did a backup napkin calculation one time and came up with $250,000,000,000 each year net cost. And that doesn’t even cover crime damages.


4 posted on 11/18/2026 1:09:24 PM PST by rlmorel (It looks hard, and it’s harder than it looks. (Elon Musk regarding rocket science))
[ Post Reply]

To: spintreebob

Kick em all out including all descendants of the slave trade since we’re such a horrible country.


5 posted on 11/18/2026 1:18:23 PM PST by maddog55 (The only thing systemic in America is the left's hatred of it!)
[ Post Reply]

To: spintreebob

Bullshit article, with simplistic accounting. It’s only designed to make headlines and give support to the political beneficiaries of mass migration.

The whole article is about “do immigrants pay more or less in taxes and take from government programs.” Its conclusions are simplistic and its data is obscure and probably highly questionable. For example, the article even admits that prior to WWII, much of their assumptions about tax collection from immigrants must be assumed.

In sum, the whole thrust of the article is - is mass migration benefit or harm TO GOVERNMENT.

Moreover, economists love to talk about “externalities” - what are the unmeasured or second-order costs of some policy.

What has mass migration, particularly illegal - done to American society - cohesion, civil society, politics and political manipulation, policing, crime (particularly unreported crime), healthcare, etc. etc..

The article completely ignores that.


6 posted on 11/18/2026 1:19:27 PM PST by PGR88
[ Post Reply]

To: spintreebob

I see no reference to a very large factor in comparing economic data for immigrants, who are lauded throughout as very beneficial, in fact, the more the merrier., to the native born population. That is, the H-1B’s , whose taxes are likely most trackable, cause the underemployment of native -born Americans in many fields where immigrants displace them.How can you be honest and even start an aalysis with out mentioning things like that ? Cost of housing to Americans? Lies, damn lies and statistics.


7 posted on 11/18/2026 1:24:19 PM PST by sopo
[ Post Reply]

To: csn vinnie

Lack of definition of “immigrant” is a serious flaw, but not a fatal flaw, in the CATO analysis. Does it include both legal and illegal? all categories? H1b, L1, L2, E1, E2, etc?
Does it include the many in the underground economy? Those “between” visa categories? The are many who lost their H1b and are waiting for their L1 or E1 or marriage or whatever.

But despite its flaws, it is factual and helpful. We lost the election. Face reality. If CATO and Heritage and MAGA and FR and 2A and ProLife and all in our coalition don’t agree on a logical, unemotional approach to immigration, the illogical, emotional approach of the other side will win.


8 posted on 11/18/2026 1:26:52 PM PST by spintreebob
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson