Posted on 11/16/2026 6:39:39 AM PST by texas booster
On Tuesday afternoon, one week after Republicans lost at least seven Senate seats and both chambers of Congress, Senate Republicans handed John Thune (R-SD) two more years as their leader. No one ran against him. No ballot was counted; he and his top lieutenants were reinstated by acclamation. An effort to postpone the vote and first debate what went wrong reportedly failed 15 to 31. The audition is over. Thune got the part: minority leader, the respectable opposition that objects loudly and yields quietly. Call it what it is. Controlled opposition.
THE MCCAIN TEMPLATE
The model already exists. John McCain spent seven years campaigning against Obamacare and won his final term in 2016 promising repeal. Then, in July 2017, with a Republican president waiting to sign, he walked onto the floor and cast the deciding vote that sank the skinny repeal bill 51 to 49. Obama himself called to thank him, McCain later wrote, and Democrats thanked him more warmly than he thought he deserved.
That was no aberration. In 2013, McCain brokered the deal that ended the GOP blockade of Obama’s executive nominees, a deal Chuck Schumer said could not have happened without him. The same year he helped write the Gang of Eight amnesty bill that cleared the Senate 68 to 32. The pattern was consistent: rhetorical opposition and procedural rescue. The legacy media—serving, as always, the Democrats’ “bipartisanship” strategy—called it independence. The Republican base called it betrayal. Both were describing the same thing.
A MAJORITY SQUANDERED
Thune’s version is subtler because it works through inaction rather than a dramatic thumbs-down. For two years, he held 53 seats, a Republican White House, and a Republican House. When President Trump warned that keeping it would cost Republicans the midterms, Thune shrugged that the votes “aren’t there.” ...
(Excerpt) Read more at amgreatness.com ...
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
The SAVE America Act, the proof-of-citizenship voting bill Trump pushed relentlessly, died in Thune’s chamber. The Uniparty does not need to defeat a reform agenda when it can simply decline to schedule it, and this is exactly what happened. Critics count roughly 50 House-passed bills sitting untouched at the Senate desk and some 135 presidential nominees left pending for a Senate that Republicans only control for a couple of months. Even Trump’s daylight saving time bill, passed by the House in July, stalled with Thune among its opponents.
None of this is new. In 2021, Thune publicly rebuked Trump’s challenge to the 2020 election results. In 2024, he won the leadership after Rick Scott (R-FL), the candidate Trump’s allies backed, was eliminated in the first round. Thune then beat John Cornyn, whose petulance would soon become apparent, 29 to 24. Observers read the result as the Senate signaling its independence from the incoming president. The institutionalists picked their man to obstruct Trump’s reform agenda. He delivered for them.
...
CONCLUDING THOUGHTS
A minority leader cannot be blamed for failing to pass anything. He gets to fight, lose with dignity, and be thanked by the other side for keeping things orderly. For an institutionalist like Thune who never wanted to touch the filibuster, minority status is not a demotion. It is relief from the expectations of a base he never shared. McCain played that role for a decade and was eulogized as a hero by the people he frustrated least—and despised by the Republican base.
Senate Republicans had one chance Tuesday to hold a hard conversation before re-hiring the man who presided over their collapse. A majority voted not to. They did not choose a leader for the fight ahead. Instead, they hired a doorman for Chuck Schumer’s Senate.
The Republican party is cooked. I don’t think anything will change, but it should. The two party system is irreparably broken. Our Founders warned us about this.
We failed Franklin’s litmus test: “A republic, if you can keep it.”
Well, you can be sure that the dems will pass their filibuster rule ASAP and Trump will sign it....
“The Republican party is cooked. I don’t think anything will change, but it should. The two party system is irreparably broken. Our Founders warned us about this.”
Agree. Sadly for us, the Republicans seem to cherish the role of back benchers. Zero responsibility, zero accountability. Simply show up and collect the grift they think is rightfully theirs. Meanwhile, the DSA has some real true believers and operates with a hive mind.
“They did not choose a leader for the fight ahead. Instead, they hired a doorman for Chuck Schumer’s Senate.”
“They hired a doormat.”......Fixed.
None of us should be voting for the Republicans anymore until the new party arrives with an entirely different group of people in it.
A party that is willing to fight for the U.S. Constitution.
Trump doesn’t have to sign it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.