Click here: to donate by Credit Card
Or here: to donate by PayPal
Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794
Thank you very much and God bless you.
Posted on 03/27/2026 7:07:12 AM PDT by Twotone
On March 20, the Georgia Court of Appeals delivered a staggering blow to the principle of bipartisan election oversight. In Fulton County Board of Commissioners v. Fulton County Republican Party, the court effectively granted the board’s partisan majority broad discretion to reject GOP nominees.
By reversing a lower court’s order to seat duly nominated Republican Board of Registration and Elections members, the court hasn’t just sided with the Fulton County Board of Commissioners, it has undermined the very safeguards meant to ensure genuine bipartisanship in Georgia’s largest county. A Defiant Pattern
This crisis is the result of a sustained campaign by Fulton’s Democratic majority to gatekeep the membership of the board. In May 2025, the board of commissioners escalated their longstanding battle with the GOP by rejecting Fulton County Republican Party nominees Julie Adams and Jason Frazier.
By August 2025, Superior Court Judge David Emerson ordered the county to seat them and, in a follow-on ruling, imposed a $10,000-a-day contempt fine — paid by taxpayers — for refusal to comply. Emerson stated in his contempt ruling that the commissioners had been “stubbornly litigious and acted in bad faith” by ignoring clear local law.
The Democrat-majority Fulton board of commissioners still refused, turning the fine into a taxpayer-funded blockade — until this latest ruling reversed both the order and the fine. Finding a Loophole
The loophole the commissioners sought has been handed to them. Presiding Judge Anne Barnes held that the board’s power to “appoint” is inherently discretionary. The court ruled that even though the local law says the governing authority “shall” make appointments from party nominations, the act of appointing is “inherently discretionary.” The commissioners therefore retain the right to exercise judgment when deciding whether to accept particular nominees. Judges should not interfere with that discretion unless the commissioners’ decision amounts to a gross abuse of discretion — that is, unless their action was arbitrary, capricious, and unreasonable.
In a statement, Georgia Republican Party Chairman Josh McKoon characterized the ruling as “Predictable but outrageous,” adding: “The Georgia Court of Appeals just handed Fulton County Democrats a veto pen over Republican nominations to the Board of Elections. ‘Shall appoint from nominations made by the party’ apparently now means ‘unless we don’t like them.’
As nominee Frazier warned, “If this holds, the Dems on the Fulton County Board of Commissioners can essentially pick their Dem Board of Elections Members, The Chair AND THE REPUBLICANS.”
Nominee Adams is currently the Fulton County Board of Registration and Elections’ only Republican member. Her term has expired, but she remains in holdover status until she or a successor is seated.
In a written statement she said, “This action destroys parity — the bipartisan balance that protects election integrity — by granting one party unchecked control over election oversight. It erodes public trust, as citizens inevitably see bias even where none exists. And it sets a dangerous precedent, signaling to other metro counties that political power, not fairness, governs who oversees elections.” The Implications: A Blueprint for Bias
This decision creates a dangerous “new normal” for Georgia. If one party can block the other’s nominees until they find someone “compliant” enough, the bipartisan balance the legislature intended to provide confidence and trust in our elections is all but dead.
It also creates a blueprint for suppression. Other counties now have a roadmap to silence dissenting voices and turn county boards of registration and elections into echo chambers. Outspoken nominees who challenge legitimate voter roll issues or processes, or insist on genuine accountability prior to certification, can be disqualified by their political opponents before they even take their seat. A Call to Action
The court of appeals created a loophole big enough to drive a truck through. Focus now turns to whether the decision will be appealed — and how long that might take.
Fulton County GOP Chair Stephanie Endres tells me the party is considering their options.
Meanwhile, lawmakers must clarify that under O.C.G.A. § 21-2-40, “shall appoint” creates a ministerial duty, not discretionary choice. The General Assembly needs to make clear that the governing board cannot refuse to seat a nominee if he or she meets statutory qualifications.
Victor Anderson, chairman of the House Government Affairs Committee, tells me the General Assembly is exploring ways, in this session, to strengthen and clarify the law on board appointments.
|
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
Tar and feathers.
Fulton county is, in general, problematic. There is no way it would ever lean right, so I don’t understand the fuss here.
I trust that the Republican majority in the legislature will change the law. That should be a given, shouldn’t it?!?!?
Idk…GOP congress wont pass a bill that practically guarantees them majorities and victories for years to come so…. Who knows
That was m maddening!! And nobody did anything about it.
The problem is that Fulton county cheating on statewide elections will ensure Democrat victories even when the majority of Georgians would have preferred a Republican.
I felt the same way. I get angry about things, but that infuriated me.
And they didn’t care. As if they KNEW they were immune.
Fulton county is, in general, problematic. There is no way it would ever lean right, so I don’t understand the fuss here.
Time for the Federal Government to oversee elections. Better yet, ban the Democratic Party as a threst to the Republic.
There never was a political solution
I assume this will be appealed to the Georgia Supreme Court.
Since counties are not sovereign - only states are - if the state supreme court does not overturn this, then the Republican state legislature in Georgia needs to rewrite the law and take over. You can’t allow corrupt political machines to carve out fiefdoms in which no oversight is allowed.
...It’s who counts the votes.
Stalin
Fulton county Georgia must be the most corrupt Democrat county in the country.
No
I’ve lived in Metro Atlanta for40 years. Fulton County and DeKalb have always been the problem children. This reason is well...you know.
Fulton county will poison statewide elections with or without cheating. The numbers will be same in any case.
Fulton county will poison statewide elections with or without cheating.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.