Posted on 10/12/2025 12:13:30 PM PDT by Twotone
Seems unconstitutional unfortunately
Apparently, Roy has yet to read and understand the United States Constitution. He’s becoming Lindsey Graham stupid.
“...Congress shall make no law respecting
an establishment of religion,
or prohibiting the free exercise thereof...”
I vehemently disagree that this is unconstitutional and am not going to debate the patently obvious fundamentals here.
The ‘stupid’ is lawful entry of enemies of the US Constitution, regardless of where the stupid originates.
Y’all forget we have the second amendment.
If “Sharia law” threatens my life I’ll kill it in self defense.
When my grandfather took his OATH of Citizenship in 1945. He had to SWEAR that he had NO allegiance to any other potentate, King, Government of any thing on Earth. Seems that the person who insists on practicing Sharia Law has his FACE sat towards MECCA and will NEVER uphold the U.S. Constitution of FREEDOM OF RELIGION. I think this would be a good stipulation... Return them to the country that they swear allegiance.
I disagree. The constitution is not a suicide pact. Islam may be a religion, but it has an ideology that makes it a danger to every OTHER religion. It requires submission - not only from its own adherents but from “infidels.” It is not compatible with a free, modern society.
If someone decided to bring back the Aztec religion, & demanded the right to sacrifice a baby on its altar, would we allow that? No. That religion would have to be banned.
The same with Islam.
Sharia law is a civil law not a religious matter.
Such a bill, based on Sharia, would be unconstitutional on its face.
Why waste our time with this kind of crap? These kinds of things make the right look EXACTLY like what the Dems call us.
Sharia law is not a religion.
It is rules based on a religion.
Like Mormonism and multiple wives.
Only if you want a prison term.
“Unconstitutional”——?
Not to me,Friend.
If they will not live by our Constitution, they forfeit any rights under our Constitution.
So, not unconstitutional fortunately.
Foreigners are supplicants.
Citizens are not.
Islam similarly is not a religion.
It’s a murderous ideology.
The Constitution was never intended to be a suicide pact.
Correct, see Key case: Reynolds v. United States (1879).
“Laws are made for the government of actions, and while they cannot interfere with mere religious belief and opinions, they may with practices.”
Adherents of Sharia Law seek to overturn the Constitution. They would not allow “free exercise of religion” to anyone else. Hence, they are not parties to the Constitution and are therefore undue of its protections.
How would I get a prison term for defending myself from a cult, that is attacking me, and violating my constitutional rights?
Especially in rural America.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.