[CFW]

Well this is an unexpected ruling. I expected the Court to rule "this law is an old law so can't be enforced" or something along those lines.

[9YearLurker]

Looks like the admin is turning up the heat to try to get many more self-deportations.

[toddausauras]

Cut off welfare etc now!

[PubliusMM]

This is very good news, indeed.

[WASCWatch]

Good for this judge. The law is unambiguous. There really isn’t any basis to question the law.

[VTenigma]

Mighty white of him to “allow” the administration to do it’s job.

[Seaplaner]

Any illegal alien voting, registering to vote, and/or facilitating other illegal aliens to register or vote should be promoted to the head of the deportation list.

[AZJeep]

This is another brilliant Trump move.
Register, and they can come for you (or not, if they decide you are really nice).
Do not register and you are in violation of law.
You will be deported the moment they catch you.

If I were an illegal, facing this dilemma, I would self deport!

[Organic Panic]

Let the democrats fight this one. Every single American citizen has to register at birth AND again every April 15th. F these illegals and deport their criminal arses. Sick of this crap.

[Vigilanteman]

Federal immigration law has long required that people who aren’t American citizens and live in the U.S., including those here illegally, register with the government.

Damn near every other civilized country in the world has their local version of this same law. Some even enforce it.

[dennisw]

“All Aliens Must Register” —— Years ago you would see these notices in US Post Office. They were required to register yearly. Back then it pertained to legal immigrants. Due to there being zero illegal immigration, at least where I lived.

The laws behind this are applicable to all immigrants. Legal and illegal.

[dennisw]

The Alien Registration Act of 1940 required that all persons who were not citizens or nationals of the United States and were living within U.S. borders go to their local post office and register their alien status with the government123. Aliens were expected to submit the completed registration form at a post office and be fingerprinted4.

[markman46]

Holy moly, back in the day 1960’s i remember that all aliens had to report to INS to register, i dont kknow just what the ducking hell the AP is going on about

[maddog55]

Interesting but highly unlikely to happen.

[StAnDeliver]

Please move this to the top of Breaking News. This is the game-changer. This decision, if combined with E-Verify enforcement, is the tipping point to get 10M to self-deport before the mid-terms.

[aquila48]

“Federal immigration law has long required that people who aren’t American citizens and live in the U.S., including those here illegally, register with the government.”

That is true. If you’re a green card holder you have to do it every year.

[ken in texas]

Back in the ‘50s, early in the year TV stations would run public service announcements warning that all aliens must register with the government or they would be forced to leave the country.

[Beave Meister]

Hear, hear. Finally a Judge that understands the Constitution.

[AndyJackson]

this law is an old law so can't be enforced

we already apply that to the Constitution.

[SENTINEL]

"this law is an old law so can't be enforced"

So is "Thou shalt not murder"...

You point out the stupidest argument the demonrats have ever made.

[ProtectOurFreedom]

"...advocates opposing the government say it hasn’t been universally used since it was first introduced in the mid-1940s." Of course. "Advocates" say "We ignored the Alien Registration Act of 1940 since it was passed and there's absolutely no reason to enforce the law now." What's the sense of even having a Congress to pass laws if they are ignored from the get-go? Just disband Congress and be done with it.