Posted on 10/24/2024 11:29:54 AM PDT by TBP
After Florida’s attorney general told the federal government in a letter last month that she was “surprised” by a move to sideline a state probe of the second suspected attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump, the Sunshine State has filed a lawsuit against U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland to “vindicate” its “sovereign interest” in separately investigating Ryan Routh as ordered by Gov. Ron DeSantis (R).
The lawsuit, filed by AG Ashley Moody (R) in Fort Pierce but this time not assigned to U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon, claims that the feds are violating the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution by invoking 18 U.S. Code § 351(f). The statute states that if “Federal investigative or prosecutive jurisdiction is asserted” in cases of attempted assassinations of major presidential candidates, then “such assertion shall suspend the exercise of jurisdiction by a State or local authority, under any applicable State or local law, until Federal action is terminated.”
The filing shows that Moody wrote a letter to FBI Director Christopher Wray and U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Florida Markenzy Lapointe, claiming that she was “surprised” to see the government citing § 351(f) before Routh had even been charged with attempted assassination.
The letter, attached as an exhibit to the lawsuit, accused the feds of a “breathtaking intrusion on state sovereignty” and a “grave mistake” in seeking to “frustrate” a state investigation.
n response one week later, Lapointe told Moody that the federal government looks “forward to continued engagement to ensure that the active federal prosecution and any potential subsequent state prosecution are appropriately sequenced, in accordance with applicable law and consistent with practical considerations.”
“The federal indictment returned last week – which post-dates your letter – resolves any potential uncertainty about whether 18 USC 351(f) applies here and by any standard represents an assertion of that provision,” the U.S. attorney said. “While as you note, in enacting 18 USC 351(f), Congress plainly envisioned federal investigative and prosecutive primacy in the first instance for attempted assassinations such as occurred here, the same provision does not preclude state prosecutions permissibly following the conclusion of the federal prosecution—and in no way prevents the sharing of federal evidence with state authorities after the federal matter has ended.”
After three weeks passed, Moody has asked U.S. District Judge K. Michael Moore, a George H.W. Bush appointee, to issue a declaratory judgment stating that Florida “may conduct its investigation without violating § 351(f)” or at least rule that the statute is “unconstitutional as applied to Florida” and prevent the feds from blocking the state probe.
“Florida sues to vindicate its sovereign interest to investigate violations of state law, as delay may impact the outcome of any prosecution,” the suit argued, noting later that “[e]vidence disappears, memories fade, and the State has no way to force the federal government to cooperate in the State’s prosecution.”
“Every day that Florida is prevented from investigating, the State’s case becomes harder to prove at trial,” the suit also said. “By contrast, the federal government suffers no injury from Florida investigating state law crimes, as the State has no intention of interfering with or obstructing the federal investigation.”
Moody asserted that the government’s “reading” of the statute at issue “would raise a substantial constitutional question because it would likely render § 351(f) unconstitutional under the Tenth Amendment.” If enforced, that would “constitute illegal executive action,” the court filing said.
I’d love to see that corrupt bastard Garland thrown in jail. He’s and his compadres have made life difficult for President Trump, his family, his friends and associates. Screw Garland the Gestapo pig.
Florida has some jurisdiction in this case. The other states do not.
Jurisdictional battles like this can cut both ways. In the Fulton County Courthouse shootings case - the escaped killer shot (and killed) a Federal Agent in Buckhead before stealing his car and making it to Gwinnett Co. where he was apprehended. Killing the federal agent opened the door to Federal prosecution, which would have been preferable to the Fulton County DA. For some reason the Feds stepped back. The Fulton DA, predecessor to Fanni Willis, screwed up jury selection and the jury was hung in the penalty phase, meaning the defendant got life instead of a needle.
In this case, the Feds will take forever to prosecute, but the time is so short before the election, I do not think it will make a difference.
“Show me the man and I’ll show you the crime.” — Merrick Garland
Garland sure flouts the law, the law he is supposed to uphold.
the regime is fine with Routh’s actions and fully intends to see that he gets off.
—
He’ll get off if possible, but he will not live long after.
Lol. I said this would happen when FLA announced they were doing their own. The feds will tie it all up in their own investigation. Simple.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.