Replies

Better than Colonel Summers in his 1982 book?

While I remember how I first thought of Summers’s 1982 book when I first heard Powell’s version in 1992 my memory isn’t good enough to remember the wording in the book.

“the work of Colonel Harry G.
Summers, who was a classmate of Powell’s at the Command and General Staff
College, proved extremely influential. It is necessary to say a brief word about
how Summers’s book came about to understand its importance. Summers
wrote the book whilst a member of the faculty of the Army War College, and
was specifically tasked with writing an analysis of the failures of US strategy
in Vietnam. Unlike the memoirs mentioned above, Summers was a serving
Military Officer at the time of writing. As such, early drafts of Summers’s
work, which came to be came to be called On Strategy: A Critical Analysis of
the Vietnam War,
10 were distributed to and commented on by the Chief of Staff
of the Army, the Vice Chief of Staff of the Army, the Army Chief of
Operations and Plans, and the Commandant of the Army War College.11 The
original document that would become the book On Strategy also contained
contributions by the CIA and the State Department. On its publication, On
Strategy was incorporated into the course reading lists at both the Army War
College and the Army Command and General Staff College. As such,
Summers’s work, much more so than the memoirs and analyses mentioned
above, carries with it the authority of being at least a semi-official account of
the perceived failures of US strategy in Vietnam, and has been read more
widely within the US Armed Forces than the other works cited above.”