Ironically, you just named two areas (economy and judges) where he was most in line with the GOPe.
Regardless, it’s not an either/or. One can appreciate what he did with the economy pre-2020 and with the judges and still think he’s not the best man for the job at this point based on where he failed.
..can you name one area that you claim he failed that you think ANY other Repub would have done better? That’s a challenge!