[marktwain]

The Supreme Court will need to define what a "commercial sale" is. If there are "commercial sales", then their must be sales which are not commercial sales.

[marktwain]

In the article: "manufacture of a firearm easier than a firearm itself"

Should be: manufacture of a firearm easier, a firearm itself

[moovova]

Bkmk

[Lockbox]

Moreover, Judge Welte inserts a completely new term into the law and the debate: “completely manufacture.”

The Final Rule does not infringe on any individuals’ or business’ ability to completely manufacturer a firearm for personal use,

It is arguable that no firearm has ever been “completely manufactured” by an individual.

Someone else mined the iron ore and refined it into steel. Someone else made the bricks to build the forge to weld the earliest barrels. Someone else sold the milling machines and/or drill presses. Someone else refined the saltpeter and sulfur, and charcoal to make the gunpowder.

Judge, it is arguable that no law has ever been “completely manufactured” by an individual.

[Macoozie]

” decades-old definitions within its longstanding regulations of federal firearms laws”

Isn’t THAT the problem? an Agency essentially creating law without Congress?

Agency “regulation” of federal law is a funny way of saying, we can do whatever we want.

SCOTUS says you can’t- Both Judges in this matter are simply wrong.

[gunnut]

With this SCOTUS, yo7 would think they would not rock the boat. Hopefully SCOTUS takes seriously “shall not be infringed”.

[dljordan]

Another Federal agency making it’s own laws.

[Mlheureux]

I thought congress made laws and the scotus decided on the constitutionality of that law. Hmm? Did we just have a nov2020 coup and elimination of the constitution? Seems like it.

[LS]

Yes. Sigh. Another slapdown is needed for these toadstools.

[Rappini]

Nobody ever pushes back on the ATF, they just roll over.

[Red in Blue PA]

Serious question.

What is the point of the ATF now? I mean, they are letting violent recidivist criminals out of prison to commit crimes again and again using guns. Known criminals were caught on camera selling guns out of the trunks of their car in Portland.

Yet I al supposed to worry about a “final rule”?

[SuperLuminal]

No Big Deal!
Our communist masters know that the pathetically servile and indolent Aamerican people will just continue to roll over and spread their collective cheeks...