Asking a judge to use common sense and defend individual liberty is a long shot for sure!
Yeah, well the 1905 scotus ruling pretty clearly denied an individual liberty exemption to a vaccine mandate.
So the ask can't be based on individual liberty because the judge is bound to follow court precedent. It's got to be based on something like giving the vaccine to already recovered covid patients results in an outcome that is contrary to the goals of the public policy.
I doubt we have the science to make that case. And asking a judge to nitpik that is a long shot.
They should be pressuring the executive to make an exception. But getting to Joe in his basement movie set is also a long shot.