Posted on 08/04/2021 6:13:44 AM PDT by Kaslin
If you want more Americans to be vaccinated against COVID-19, emphasizing that they could still catch the disease and transmit it to others even after they get their shots may not be the best strategy. Yet that is what the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention did last week, generating "alarmist" and "hyperbolic" press coverage that dismayed Biden administration officials who rightly worried that it would deter vaccination.
Major news outlets deserve criticism for hyping the danger posed by breakthrough infections. But they were taking their cues from federal officials who exaggerated that danger, even while trying to reassure the public about the effectiveness of vaccines.
With COVID-19 cases caused by the especially contagious delta variant of the coronavirus surging in many parts of the country, the main priority should be persuading vaccine-leery Americans that widespread inoculation is the key to conquering the pandemic and returning to normal life. Notwithstanding the delta variant, vaccines remain highly effective at preventing life-threatening COVID-19 symptoms, as reflected in the fact that vaccinated Americans account for a tiny share of hospitalizations and deaths.
It has always been clear that vaccines are not completely effective at preventing infection, and data from other countries suggest that the risk of breakthrough infections is higher now that the delta variant accounts for the vast majority of new cases. Yet unvaccinated people are still much more likely to be infected than vaccinated people.
That point was frequently lost in the breathless reporting on the CDC's decision to recommend that vaccinated Americans who live in "areas of substantial or high transmission" resume wearing face masks in public places. CDC Director Rochelle Walensky and Ben Wakana, deputy director of strategic communications and engagement for the White House COVID-19 Response Team, contributed to the confusion by grossly exaggerating the likelihood of breakthrough infections.
The estimates offered by Walensky and Wakana -- which seemed to be based on a misunderstanding of the effectiveness rates reported in vaccine studies -- implied that vaccinated people face a higher) risk of infection than unvaccinated people do. That message was plainly inconsistent with the CDC's repeated statements that breakthrough infections remain "rare" and that unvaccinated people account for "the vast majority" of virus transmission.
The official justification for the CDC's new mask advice was evidence indicating that viral loads in nasal samples from vaccinated people infected by the delta variant were similar to those in samples from unvaccinated people.
"High viral loads suggest an increased risk of transmission and raised concern that, unlike with other variants, vaccinated people infected with delta can transmit the virus," Walensky said on Friday, when the CDC published a study of a July outbreak in Provincetown, Massachusetts.
Contrary to what the ensuing press coverage implied, the CDC did not actually say that vaccinated carriers were just as likely to transmit the virus as unvaccinated carriers. On that score, the implications of the Provincetown study remain unclear, and researchers are still trying to determine the extent to which the Massachusetts cases described by the CDC were caused by vaccinated carriers.
"I want to be clear," Walensky told reporters on Monday. "While vaccinated people can spread the virus if they get a breakthrough infection, the odds of them getting sick in the first place are far lower than (the odds for) those who are unvaccinated."
That clarity is welcome, if belated. But leaving aside the misinformation disseminated by Walensky and Wakana, the CDC's new mask guidance itself implied that vaccinated Americans are playing an important role in spreading the delta variant, even as Wakana emphasized that "vaccinated individuals represent a VERY SMALL amount of transmission occurring around the country."
A recent increase in daily vaccination numbers suggests that the surge in COVID-19 cases and reports about dying patients who regretted their decision to eschew vaccines have persuaded some waverers. The Biden administration should focus on encouraging that trend instead of sending mixed messages that undermine public confidence in vaccines.
Discourage? Had no plans to get it. Now, they are more firmly locked in.
I'm personally looking forward to all of these vaccine mandate corporations bringing their people back into offices to see how quickly variants spread. Without the unvaccinated strawmen, it may become painfully obvious that the vaccinated are the spreaders.
But of course most organizations have built in exception/accommodation policies, so if outbreaks occur, those with accommodations will be blamed as patient(s) zero.
That clarity is welcome, if belated. But leaving aside the misinformation disseminated by Walensky and Wakana, the CDC's new mask guidance itself implied that vaccinated Americans are playing an important role in spreading the delta variant, even as Wakana emphasized that "vaccinated individuals represent a VERY SMALL amount of transmission occurring around the country."
Clarity? If a person lies 100 times, what makes the 101st lie "clear"?
It appears that with all of the mask mandates coming back and increased discussion of lockdowns, that the vaccine was a total waste of time....just in time for the teachers to return to school (funny coincidence).
“vaccinated individuals represent a VERY SMALL amount of transmission occurring around the country.”
Why do the vaccines work so much better in the US than they do in Israel, England, Scotland and Singapore? We should share our expertise with them.
Or whatever secret sauce the deep state uses in its counting methods.
Everything Joe and Co. do and say proves daily, almost hourly, that they are totally adrift on this thing.
They are very obviously making it up as they go along and it's apparent that it was like that from the very start.
They started something they can't control and now, they're riding the tiger. Even with the wholesale complicity of the most corrupt, unprincipled an next-to-worthless media we have ever had, they cannot extricate themselves.
Well duh…the ‘vaccine’ is extremely dangerous and doesn’t work…what’s too like???
Fake News. Natural immunity has been shown to be superior to natural immunization from surviving CoVID infection.
It’s possible my tinfoil hat is on too tight, but I just had this thought: “What if they don’t WANT everyone to get the jab? As, the LAST thing they would want is for everyone to have it, as they NEED the holdouts to blame whenever the new variant flares up. They need someone to blame so as to cover their own screw ups.”
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.