The Oldest Temptation in the Book

Townhall.com ^ | October 21, 2020 | Bill Murchison

[Kaslin]

Back to where we left off the other day: democracy's varied discontents staring us straight in our blurred and reddening eyes, obscuring once-familiar loyalties and understandings.

Modern democracy as a bloodier and bloodier power struggle, our self-chosen political classes' refusal to recognize reality as a barrier to the achievement of new and fancy ideals - such are the reminders that you and I, my brothers and sisters, must be mighty careful in our political choices. We can always make things worse than they are, and how they are isn't great.

Under a Chinese-style dictator, say, the act of choosing with integrity and wisdom offers no difficulties. Just cast your vote (if allowed), and wait for the leadership to decide whether you did it right.

Democracy exhibits under a different marquee on account of its regard for citizens as participants instead of onlookers. Democracy's decidedly unsnooty operations bring to the fore various principles that complement rather than contradict nature, e.g., discernment and rational judgment. Democracy, when it works right, discourages the rash, the reckless, the destructive, the disorderly.

So, where's the argument? Don't we know all this?

Sadly, I reply: Nope. If we know it, we don't show it. We've come, in the 21st century, to equate democratic politics with "guerre a outrance" -- war to the veritable limits of possibility. We don't want peace; we want obliteration. We've come to this point accidentally by expecting House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Rep. Adam Schiff and, yes, President Donald Trump actually, incredibly, to make the world a better place, when, in fact, their job ought just to be affording scope for peaceful, rational human behavior and development.

How's that for a redefinition of the ordeal through which we're passing -- an ordeal that will continue long past Nov. 3 on account of our insistence of seeing politics as earthly salvation? A thing, my brothers and sisters, it ain't -- and ain't never going to be, neither, because salvation isn't supposed to be the aim of democratic politics. Salvation rests in other hands -- not necessarily of an earthly kind.

Politics as a power quest is the monster we face in our time -- stomping, smashing the trees as it moves forward, Godzilla on the loose, with no time for objection to its aspirations. Are politicians bad people? Maybe no worse, as a class, than writers and journalists. Nonetheless, their quest for power is, to my way of thinking, the force likeliest to bring democracy crashing down on us as power becomes the all-encompassing aim rather than laws and procedures and opinions meant to ensure the fruitful exercise of power.

I don't think you have to be a Trumpian or a Bidenist to acknowledge such realities. All you need to do, I think, is adjust your specs. Then look around. Take in the weary sight of grand designs pushed far beyond their inherent value or usefulness by politicians and the "public intellectuals" who egg them on.

The psalmist, to the consternation of this new power class, got it right a sheaf of centuries ago: "O put not your trust in princes, nor in any child of man (italics mine); for there is no help in them." It's the Lord, the psalmist continues, "who helpeth them that are fallen" and "careth for the righteous." Really? Our celebrated "nones" don't see it that way -- the folk who characterize, when conversing with survey-takers, their own religious affiliation as "none."

Of these there are quite a lot. They tend either to ignore power politics or invest them with profound meaning -- as do lots of today's Americans, at the bidding of journalists, broadcasters, professors, think tank inhabitants and, naturally, politicians, elected or aspiring to that station. These want to frame our elections, especially the present one, as potential turning points in history.

It is not that democratic elections are without relevance to daily lives and fortunes. The truth is diametrically opposite that. A still larger truth is that the aim of achieving power over fellow humans is the oldest temptation in the book, as well as the one likeliest to undermine the golden gains promised us on Nov. 3 by - who else? - the architects of those promises.

[RatRipper]

Pretty clear to me the Rat party is out to enslave us. Trump is certainly not a gleaming Messiah, but he has a far more rational, reasonable view of what our government is supposed to be. To an extent, he has to seek power to keep it away from the utterly evil commie Rats. Would be far better if the Rats would restrain the quest for, and use of, governmental power. But they don’t, haven’t for years. They have made us slaves to the dictates of government, and THAT IS EVIL.

[coxdenis32]

I recommend reading the book Scarlet Letter that made me think about the correctness of our life. We shouldn’t blame the government for our problems. Our life is a mirror of our actions