Barrett would definitely be my choice. She at least has a track record of conservative opinions. Id be a bit wary of Lagoa.. first off, she garnered the votes of 27 dems when she was confirmed. That, along with her relatively scant track record, speaks to a redux of David Souter, who GHWB appointed without knowing his stances on abortion, 2A, etc.
Democrat support is a definite red flag.
I also like Britt Grant, confirmed to 11th Circuit on July 31, 2018, on a vote of 52-46:
Rest assured the Left does NOT want ACB...ha...just realized she’ll fit in nicely as she has a three letter acronym...ACB replaces RBG :)
That is how I read Lagoa also.
The true good picks bring out the Crazy Left.
Bork
Thomas
Kavanagh