Liking Hamilton is about subjective impressions; the weightier matters are about objective reality.
“the weightier matters are about objective reality”
Well, that’s a problem. Our enemies have rejected the notion of “objective reality”, so you cannot even meaningfully discuss those matters with them.
the weightier matters are about objective reality.
No. The truth is that people with differing opinions do see “objective reality” from different views. Listen. Understand your fellow debater. Craft your argument to him; share how your opinion has bettered your life. You will have more effect than insulting him by insisting your point is more objective than his.