Tax payer here. I’m going to say hell no.
Unless we’re talking about serious malpractice of justice, when a captain is removed for administratice cause or fault he should stay removed.
In the business world, if you fire someone for cause, even if that cause is a minor infraction, you do not give the same job back.
The man with the final say, Secretary of Defense Mark Esper has not yet reached a decision. Just like in civilian life, sometimes initial rulings are reversed on appeal.