Posted on 11/15/2019 4:52:35 PM PST by rintintin
This plan would be so secret that no one would even have proof of who actually voted for it. They would only have the final tally that said that everyone did.
Article I: and the Yeas and Nays of the Members of either House on any question shall, at the Desire of one fifth of those Present, be entered on the Journal.
You need 20 Senators to require a public vote, if secrecy has been imposed.
Elections are by secret ballot. Votes in Congress are different.
I! Me! I! Am! Superior!
Every Republican in Congress would be voted out, House and Senate, and they would deserve it.
They do stuff like voice votes and unanimous consent, but voting in secret without recording the votes is a horse of another color.
So let me get this straight. The Anons on 4chan and 8chan are full of it and to be ignored at all cost but the Anons in impeachment are to be believed without question.
The GOP Senate members would be doing this as their final living act.
Thanks!
Apparently, they think they are clever.
Do these idiots honestly think we will not hunt them down?
But first they are going to land on the sun. Don’t worry, they’ll be okay because they will be landing at night.
Gibsonguy to Williams: “This was a question I had. Could mitt and a few traitors side up with all the rats and force a secret ballot? Would Mitch have to allow it? Would it be legal? If its a secret ballot Id say the odds are fifty-fifty at best Trump survives. Its no accident this little scumbags idea keeps popping up like its a new story.”
Williams to Gibsonguy: “Oh please the Republicans would still be destroyed if they oust the president in a secret ballot. The whole idea is preposterous. The voters would demand to know how their senators voted.”
To Williams: There would be a lot of negative media coverage stating that it was right and just, plus most voters would not notice.
Well I would agree it would be a tipping point l really think all hell would break loose if they tried this. I just wondered about the legal question. I wonder how many Rinos have the attitude that we will be mad but well get over it and accept Pence because where else are we going to go? They will be in for hell surprise when we drag their asses out of the Capital and burn it to the ground.
Even though jury deliberations are conducted in secret, the defense has the right to have the judge poll the jurors in public as to how they voted on each count.
So only 20 Senators can force it to be public if they try this BS? Hmm does Trump have that many he can rely on? Sad that is even in doubt.
Oust him and there will be so much blood in the streets it will make Iraq and syria look like a pacifist nunnery. Oust him secretly and all bets are off. The deep swamps Dictatorship will be overt
“Im not even sure the Senate can have secret votes of any kind. If you dont record each persons vote how can the result be official?”
My understanding is that each house of Congress has total authority to set its own rules. The Senate could adopt a rule allowing for the vote after an impeachment trial to be by a secret ballot, with only the number voting to convict or acquit being reported, but not who voted which way. I’m not a lawyer or a parliamentarian, so I could easily be wrong, but I think a rule can be adopted by a mere majority vote. Assuming all the Democrats (45) vote for the secret vote rule and the 2 Independents also vote that way, it would take 4 Republicans to force the adoption of the rule. I assume the vote on the rule would be a recorded roll call.
If they do it, theyll do it over Christmas when people are distracted
yes. Open the dictionary under gutless and theres a picture of a (generic) Republican senator. Takes Yer pick
Free countries do not do secret votes.
We will overthrow the whole fuching mess if this sh1t begins. We also know the names of the people to go after.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.