[Mrs. Don-o]

That's a superficial reading of a rather careful and principled argument.

Scalia and Thomas ---in the "Catholic" category too, --- are cited by Zmirak as role models who understand the necessary difference between a jurist and a prelate.

[Hugh the Scot]

Zimrak gave no example in his analysis for Ms. Barrett recusing herself, or deciding a case outside the relevant law, based on her Catholicism.

She’s shown herself capable of doing what’s right legally, while holding and expressing a different opinion personally.

My reading was neither superficial, nor incorrect.