However, we'll never know this kids' true motive for knocking at this door asking for directions to the school he attends everyday.
Additionally, let's not forget that the standard to be imposed in the accused in such a situation is supposed to be "would a reasonable person act in the same way, given their state of mind at that moment?". A jury might well find that the homeowner failed that test—notwithstanding the wife's clear overreaction to the situation.
Presuming that the accused was apparently found guilty by a jury of his peers, I don't have an issue with the convictions—assuming that said jury was fully informed. But having said that, I think that this sort of incident is better seen as a "no harm, no foul" situation, where "everyone has learned important lessons". Thus, putting this homeowner behind bars with some real criminals—especially for any significant length of time—is not what I'd consider "justice".
"Let the punishment fit the crime"; in this instance I am of the opinion that the penalty imposed was too severe...
Disagree. Firing a shot over a kid's head seems quite reasonable to me. The message is "Don't come back."
Additionally, let's not forget that the standard to be imposed in the accused in such a situation is supposed to be "would a reasonable person act in the same way, given their state of mind at that moment?". A jury might well find that the homeowner failed that test—notwithstanding the wife's clear overreaction to the situation.
I can't see the video, but someone else who did said that it didn't look like he fired the gun on purpose. Accidental discharge is a different animal. I actually find that more offensive than a deliberate discharge intentionally aimed away.
"Let the punishment fit the crime"; in this instance I am of the opinion that the penalty imposed was too severe...
What does it cost to keep an inmate nowadays? Isn't it like $40,000/year? They are going to spend a minimum of $160,000 to keep this guy locked up?
Stupid.
What important lesson did the kid learn?
Better be fast if you’re going to be black?