Evangelicals have absolutely no horse in this race whatsoever. Amy Coney Barrett would worry them because she seems unlikely to stand her ground on Vatican lobbying and evangelicals do not see eye to eye with the Vatican particularly on the issues of open borders and socialism. She has said that she would recuse herself from cases that conflict with her faith, and that would be perfectly fine in a lower court where cases could just be passed on to another judge but that remedy isn’t an option here. Plus 2/3 of the Supreme Court is Catholic. Wouldn’t those other justices also be candidates for recusal on the same reasoning?
Don’t like them Catholics, do you?