Posted on 07/07/2018 8:08:45 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
The late Charles Krauthammer was right about the rules of good writing. The use of the first-person pronoun in opinion writing is a cardinal sin.
To get a sense of how bad someone's writing is count the number of times he or she deploys the Imperial "I" on the page. Krauthammer considered a single "I" in a piece to be a failure.
Use "I" when the passive-form alternative is too clumsy. Or, when the writer herself has earned the right to, because of her relevance to the story. (The story itself, naturally, should have relevance.) The second is my excuse here.
As a legal immigrant to the U.S., now an American citizen, I have a right to insert myself into the noisy narrative.
As a legal immigrant who was separated from her daughter, herself a legal immigrant, the onus is on me to share a scurrilous story that is part of a pattern:
America's immigration policy—driven as it is by policy makers and enforces—exalts and privileges those of low moral character. It rewards law-breakers, giving them the courtesy and consideration not given to high-value, legal immigrants.
The same U.S. immigration law enforcers who cater so kindly to each illegal immigrant—the kind that is a drain on the country and has no right to be in the country—stripped my daughter of her American permanent residency privileges.
A young person travels alone and gets bamboozled at the border-crossing in Blaine, Washington State. So, they strip her of her green card.
That's our immigration story.
My girl was studying in Canada. She got intimidated at the border and gave the wrong answer to her petty American inquisitor. So, she was quick-marched into a small booth and peppered with more questions meant to terrify.
With an intimidating display of machismo, the burly men of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) bullied a young girl into relinquishing her right of permanent residency (also the road to citizenship).
La Bandida was at bay. America was finally safe.
More fundamentally, hers was not an ill-gotten green card.
The principal sponsor, a Ph.D. in electrical engineering, had entered the U.S. on an O-1 visa. Unlike the H-1B visa,the 0-1 visa doesn't replace Americans; it adds to them. For it is granted to those with "extraordinary ability in the fields of science, education, business or athletics." The O-1 necessitates "a level of expertise indicating that the person is one of the small percentage who has risen to the very top of the field of endeavor."
Not by deceit did my child gain her green card. But by deceit is how the swarms on the border will get theirs. The squeaky wheels squatting on the southern border, funneled daily into the interior to create facts on the ground, are notrefugees or legitimate asylum seekers. Rather, they are merely from what President Trump has termed "s--thhole countries." By that criteria, Americans could be forced to welcome the world.
A refugee, conversely, is an individual who is persecuted on the basis "of race, religion, nationality, and/or membership in a particular social group or political opinion."Like my South-African compatriots, who, every day, are culled like springbok in a hunting safari. But for South Africans, U.S. refugee and immigration authorities reserve their unalloyed prejudice.
Back to la bandida .Was my daughter allowed a phone call to her parents? No! What about access to an immigration attorney? No!
A well-behaved, legal resident, who did not enter the USA to cause trouble, this young lady obeyed the laws of the country. She did not defy its enforces. Timidly, she accepted her lot.
Our daughter had her hard-won green card stripped by state bullies because she gave the wrong answer to a trick bureaucratic question.
Her case, no doubt, was further hindered by the fact that she simply was not a sympathetic "type." After all, she speaks good English, was attached to productive people, residing lawfully in their own home in the U.S., mere hours away. And she is not of a more exotic persuasion. At least not visibly so.
No, not simpatico at all.
So, she was tossed out of the United States of America like so much trash.
I hazard that had my daughter spoken in tongues or rendered a "good" Pidgin English; had she cried, created a scene; called for the presstitutes and the immigration advocates—she'd have "passed" with flying colors and would have been sent on her merry way.
It's as though people of early American probity, to paraphrase writer Mary McGrory, are carefully and purposefully weeded out by contemporary America's immigration policies and policy makers. (Until Trump.)
Indeed, we South Africans are just not part of the "multicultural noise machine," now sitting on the southern border seething with rage, poised to make common purpose with America’s professional merchants of racial hatred.
We are not pushy. We do things the right way. And we swallow the pain and indignity.
All this was in 2006 or thereabouts, shortly after the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) changed its name to USCIS. Only now, in 2018, has mother (me) been able to "share my story." (There's another vernacular tumor that should be excised by all decent editors.)
"Family values don't stop at the Rio Grande," roared George W. Bush, at the time.
El presidente forgot to mention that family values do stop with the decent, documented residents of the United States.
Why did you do that to your child? Get your ass out!!
RE: Why did you do that to your child?
Do what? Let her study in Canada? What’s wrong with that?
What are you talking about?
Her story would be better if it were comprehensible.
So sad nobama is too choomed out to care.
What on earth are you talking about????????????
.
Is this one of those spam emails?
I read one of her books and it was terrific,about the mess that South Africa is in today.————this article was confusing,though.
.
One would think a Green Card holder would do everything possible to be/stay put in the USA.
What question did the author’s daughter answer incorrectly? So far as I can tell, the author does not say. As a result, her story doesn’t make much sense.
A Green card is a legitimate ID to enter the US from Canada.
.
All people in prison are separated from their loved ones. Oh how awful. We need to all write the President and complain about this. Sarc.
wow. if this is true (and i don’t doubt it is even though it’s been a long time since 2006), what a travesty of injustice and a simultaneous loss for our nation and this family.
perhaps our border agents at the time would not have been so jaded and incompetent in this case, if they’d had good leadership and a secure border at the time. very sad story.
build the wall Mr President. secure the border. secure the interior. deport illegal aliens with families intact. enforce the existing laws. ban chain-migration. support ICE. encourage self-deportation. support legal immigrants. may God help you to keep your promises.
There is no back story-—the main complaint is that illegals are treated better at the border than her daughter,a legal immigrant,was treated at the border.
She has a point.
.
Congratulations on becoming and American Citizen. Please bring us up to date on what’s been happening with your daughter in the intervening twelve years.
Congratulations on becoming an American Citizen. Please bring us up to date on what’s been happening with your daughter in the intervening twelve years.
Where did it give a 12 year old date?
Why did you do that to your child? Get your ass out!!
*********************************
To whom is that directed? Do what to his/her child? Get out of what?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.