Interesting analysis.
So it seems that Colorado Civil Rights commission is either going to have to allow Phillips to refuse to bake the cake based on his religious values or its going to have to require the other bakers to bake the cakes with statements derogatory to gay marriage despite their secular values.
In response to this pathetically weak ruling, Colorado will:
Allow bakers to refuse to bake anti-gay cakes: “Persons cannot be forced by the state to engage in hate speech”.
Continue to require bakers to create cakes for homosexual weddings: “It is discrimination to deny services to persons based on sexual orientation. Providing equal service to all members of the general public in no way interferes with a person’s free exercise of his religion.”