Yes, I know it's a loyalty oath. However, is it so onerous to promise to obey the legally passed laws of the country they are living in? Such as, the First thru the Tenth Amendments?
I believe in the ruling the Judge dismissed any punitive damages as a consequence of YAF’s lawsuit. So it was somewhat of a pyrrhic victory. They would only be able to collect on actual damages which would probably just be lawyers fee.
Beside, the progressives will find a way to continue to impinge on YAF and civil rights of conservatives.